I would probably pick the 2025 team due to how naturally their performances captured each character and reluctantly the new Doom. Though, I would love to see both Silver Surfers on screen.
Exciting_Memory98372025-10-24 01:50
In order from slides
2005
2025
2005
2015
2025
2025
CherAli2025-10-24 01:55
First person to understand my rules, maybe I explained this badly 😅
petrowski72025-10-24 01:52
2025 except Evans as Human Torch
No_Mood_75152025-10-24 01:56
My pick exactly
Darth_Thor2025-10-24 02:15
Specifically the version from Deadpool and Wolverine
petrowski72025-10-24 03:35
I don’t even know what half those words mean!!!
Silo-Joe2025-10-24 04:32
Lucas Lee is in the Deadpool Wolverine movie.
petrowski72025-10-24 04:34
Now you listen up and you listen hard, bucko
SP4CEM4N_SPIFF2025-10-24 06:07
Can he do a thingy on that rail tho?
neutralcoder2025-10-24 01:54
Everyone from 2025 felt perfect.
El_Quetzal2025-10-24 01:54
All from the mid 2000s, at least they were well cast, unlike the new one who were badly cast. Specially reed and sue
A_Serious_House2025-10-24 01:54
2005 Reed and Thing, 2025 Storm siblings
Doom: 1995 version
Surfer: 2025 version, her surfing was INCREDIBLE.
BravoLeader30002025-10-24 02:11
Her surfing after the FF when they were going light speed away from Galactus was awesome!
TheIJDGuy2025-10-24 02:12
This I can definitely agree with, ESPECIALLY 95 Doom. Our only good live action version (hopefully so far!)
Ghetto_Phenom2025-10-24 03:10
Kind of funny but apparently mark ruffalo auditioned for that 95 doom role. Anyways agree on that one.
SmellsLikeHerb2025-10-24 01:58
All 3 Sue Storms and the big Thing.
mag08022025-10-24 02:38
All 3 things and Jessica alba?
decypher122025-10-24 02:10
2025 versions are perfect for me.
mr90252025-10-24 02:28
I’m gonna stick with Kraszsienzkiikizi as the ideal Reed. Hot take. I know.
VallyMeowy2025-10-24 02:31
My choices too. Except for Doom we haven’t seen RDJ’s version yet so I vote the original
surferdude72272025-10-24 02:38
Yeah, I feel like RDJ is gonna kill it, but we just don’t know yet. Gotta go with the Julian McMahon Doom.
creepingkg2025-10-24 02:37
Except the human torch for me. I liked Chris Evans a lot more
decypher122025-10-24 02:38
Human touch 2025 looks perfect for me. I love the fact that he flirt with female surfer.
jojopojo642025-10-24 03:20
He also had an extremely intelligent side that wasn't really touched upon in the other films - which makes sense considering he's a *goddamn astronaut.*
Smaragd442025-10-24 03:46
Chris Evans torch was too much of an asshole
MrNobody_02025-10-24 04:41
It's the only one where Johnny and Sue look like they're actually related.
perfectpencil2025-10-24 09:17
I'm amazed that shalla bal actually beat Norin Rad, for me. Silver Surfer is my all time #1 favorite comic book character and I thought his old appearance was pretty good... But this new version was everything I wanted from the character and more. She felt closer to the comic version of silver surfer than I expected.
neeohh2025-10-24 02:12
Ioan. Chiklis Thing. Quinn Torch. Kirby Sue.
BathInevitable87552025-10-24 02:41
I definitely agree Ioan is the best Fantastic. Ebon and Chiklis are both good as Thing. Chris Evans is too iconic but Quinn's Johnny is too perfect, they are both Johnny, his douchebag side and his genius resourceful side. All of the Sue's are phenomenal, but Kirby's mom mode is too good. 2005 is better action sequences but 2025 is better story and character development.
Armandonerd2025-10-24 03:56
Ebon didn't feel like or he was from New York with that Italian accent.
Variation_Afraid2025-10-24 04:34
I get everyone has their favorites but you are absolutely faded if you think loan is the best mr fantastic, Pedro’s reed is literally comic book accurate
BathInevitable87552025-10-24 07:15
They are both pretty good, but Pedro got outshined by the rest of the cast in perspective to their characters. Ioan also used his powers more and in more creative ways. Pedro showed Reed as a super genius inventor but he didn't actually use his powers that much except for convenience. They are both good, I think Ioan Mr Fantastic is better, but Pedro Reed is better
MysteriousSalt57432025-10-24 04:18
solid choices, that thing is always a solid pick for durability
Miguelohara0992025-10-24 02:13
Reed: Top Left
Ben: Very top
Johnny: Far Left
Sue: Far Right (but it’s close with JA being second)
Doom: Far Left
Silver Surfer: Left
Dakotes732025-10-24 02:13
John Krasinsky (Jim) fits it perfectly!
SwedishSmurf2025-10-24 02:14
I loved the 2025 cast, they felt like an actual family. Only cast i’m torn over is 2005 Mr Fantastic since Ioan Gruffudd IS Mr Fantastic in my eyes.
Variation_Afraid2025-10-24 04:36
Pedro’s more accurate to the comics brother man
Randolpho2025-10-24 11:00
Gruffudd is such an underutilized talent.
Gonna have to go watch Hornblower again
hel105_2025-10-24 02:15
Not sure if I answered the question correctly but I picked Jessica Alba 4 times and I feel good about it.
ThePenultimateWaltz2025-10-24 02:37
Scholander2025-10-24 02:38
I would add the naked silver lady to that lineup, personally.
Armandonerd2025-10-24 03:56
Shala-bala Silver Surfer
TotakekeSlider2025-10-24 02:57
Me too, but it’s the Thing 4 times. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
unsupported2025-10-24 12:28
Played by Jessica Alba?
SexlexiaSufferer2025-10-24 13:01
Show me that thingussy
No-Abalone17852025-10-24 05:33
ylmao honestly, sometimes you just gotta go with who you like best
Lucky_Union_61922025-10-24 05:48
its fantastic
Bad_Username-19992025-10-24 07:43
AsteroidMike2025-10-24 02:19
Pascal Reed
Chiklis Thing
Evans Johnny
Alba Sue
Single-Pianist-22112025-10-24 02:24
2005 cast but swap in Vanessa Kirby for Jessica Alba
labbla2025-10-24 02:25
1994 Fantastic Four
ich-bin-on-that-shit2025-10-24 02:26
2025, enough of this shit.
Stressy-And-Depressy2025-10-24 02:28
unpopular opinion: I'm taking the entire Fan4stic cast. the movie was obviously bad, but they had such a dynamite cast to pull it off & still absolutely fumbled it
TheRealGrifter2025-10-24 02:30
2025 for everyone but Pedro. Swap in John Krasinski.
Top_Reindeer33962025-10-24 02:30
Marvel rivals
(because I can play with them)
DarkSonic06ki2025-10-24 02:31
You know what I liked Michael b Jordan as the human torch
uhateonhaters2025-10-24 06:27
We are on an island.
justafanboy10102025-10-24 08:03
Hell yeah!!
hankscorpio10312025-10-24 02:34
I thought Ben Grimm with a beard looked amazing
Wakattack002025-10-24 02:34
MCU versions clean sweep for me. Kirby is the best overall. She was outstanding.
HyruleBalverine2025-10-24 02:34
You forgot the OGs! [https://tse4.mm.bing.net/th/id/OIP.1LbuPs2M5xDHB6U1gTQozwAAAA?rs=1&pid=ImgDetMain&o=7&rm=3](https://tse4.mm.bing.net/th/id/OIP.1LbuPs2M5xDHB6U1gTQozwAAAA?rs=1&pid=ImgDetMain&o=7&rm=3)
jojopojo642025-10-24 03:21
Gonna be honest: of all the teams, they had the best hair lol
Mr_E_992025-10-24 02:37
Johnny: Love all 3 actors as a whole, but latest one was so much better than the others at giving him more depth than just an idiot hot head
Same goes for Sue and Thing. 2005 versions were alright but Sue over sexualized and the Thing was not given much depth in character
Reed Richards I honestly didn't think Pedro Pascal was the best fit and John Krasinski could have had the most potential with it
Dr Doom, definitely 2005, though I'm optimistic even though there are better castings that RDJr will do a good job
And Silver Surfer definitely 2005/7
EasyConnection26062025-10-24 02:39
The first cast with full cgi thing 💯🤘🏻👍🏻
BathInevitable87552025-10-24 02:39
2005 and 2025 both did the characters well, 2025 is a lot more family oriented but 2005 did the characters a good way too. Doom in both is good, he carried the 2015 movie. Chris Evans Johnny is just way too iconic.
FrostyBoom2025-10-24 02:40
Ioan, Ebon, Chris Evans, Vanessa, Doug Jones/Lawrence Fishburne. Can't say anything about RDJ's doom so I'd pick Julian McMahon's.
fart_fig_newton2025-10-24 02:46
Julian McMahon was not just a good Doom, he also played Victor outside of the suit very well. Really would have loved a cameo from his Doom in this Multiverse Saga, he was an underrated actor. RIP
FrostyBoom2025-10-24 02:50
Yeah, I don't know if it's nostalgia since they're old but I recall liking those movies despite the issues and Doom was always my favorite character. Might rewatch them soon to see how they hold up with my older, nitpickier self.
SolitaryCellist2025-10-24 02:40
Is that really what Doom looked like in 2015? Everything I learn about that movie validates my decision to not watch it.
Wtygrrr2025-10-24 02:43
Why are we picking between two entirely different characters in the last one?
hdgrbodnd2025-10-24 02:46
Pascal, chiclis, quinn, and kirby
BLaZeTaZeR9992025-10-24 02:48
25 mr fantastic and invisible woman and 05 thing human torch dr doom and silver surfer
CaptHayfever2025-10-24 02:57
* Because of the 2-per-team limitation: Pascal, Evans, Kirby, Chiklis.
* If there wasn't a limitation: Pascal, Quinn, Kirby, Chiklis.
* Doom: Downey, even though I haven't even seen it yet, because the 2015 Doom was atrocious & I don't like McMahon in anything.
* Surfer: This one's hard because they were both good. I'll go Garner for the better visuals.
Possible_Hokie_CO262025-10-24 02:57
John Krasinski, Chiklis, Evans, Kirby
ApexInTheRough2025-10-24 02:59
2005 Reed & Thing, 2025 Johnny & Sue, RDJ, Doug Jones
franktelevision2025-10-24 02:59
Ioan, Evans, Ebon, Alba (mostly because she was so hot!)
CheapTactics2025-10-24 03:01
Who is picking anyone from the fant4rstic movie? They're the blandest characters in existence.
Edboy7962025-10-24 03:02
As much as he seemed to be fantastic, I would exclude Krazinski since he was in a sequence and not a full movie
FairyGodmothersUnion2025-10-24 03:04
Ioan, Chiklis, Evans, Kirby. Julian McMahon did a great job. I like both Silver Surfers.
justafanboy10102025-10-24 08:03
Agreed
Gokai_Ultra2025-10-24 03:08
2005 Reed
2025 Ben
2025 Johnny
2005 Sue
RDJ Doom
2025 Surfer
glimmerfox2025-10-24 03:17
This is Roger Corman erasure
EntertainmentQuick472025-10-24 03:24
John Krasinksi Reed Richards, 2025 Thing, 2025 Johnny, Jessica Alba Sue Storm, and the 90s version of Dr Doom
Confident-Gur-32242025-10-24 03:27
I pick all the original except swap the Thing for the 2025 version.
Glum_Kaleidoscope6012025-10-24 03:30
Ioan, Ebon, MBJ, Kirby
Front-Advantage-70352025-10-24 03:31
2005, 2005, 2005 aaaaand…. 2005.
EDIT: didn’t realize there were more than 4 options for the F4 so
I’ll also take RDJ even though i love Julian McMahon, and then 2007 since they did it first.
PhillipJ3ffries2025-10-24 03:32
Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Chris Evans, Michael Chiklis
Smaragd442025-10-24 03:45
2025 for all 4
Armandonerd2025-10-24 03:55
Ioan Gruffud's Mr. Fantastic
Michael Chiklis's The Thing
Vanessa Kirby's Invisible Woman
Joseph Quinn's Human Torch
Julian McMahon's Dr. Doom
Laurence Fishburne's Silver Surfer
FancySk8erGirl2025-10-24 03:59
2005 has all the best actors imo
Zach1822025-10-24 04:01
Gruffudd
Kirby
Quinn
Chiklis w/ 2025 design.
vfoster2025-10-24 04:01
Reed: Ioan Gruffudd.
Ben: Michael Chiklis.
Johnny: Chris Evans.
Sue: Vanessa Kirby.
The rules are kinda arbitrary (only 2 from the same team), so I broke them. The 1995 team was perfect for me, but I liked Kirby's Sue much better. I don't have a preference for Doom. And Shalla Bal and Norrin Radd are two different characters that I don't particularly wish to choose between either. Ralph Ineson's Galactus was the best yet (not that there has really been any competition).
Midnight-Basilisk992025-10-24 04:02
Mr Fantastic- Pedro Pascal
The Thing- Michael Chiklis
Human Torch- Joseph Quinn
Invisible Woman- Jessica Alba
Dr Doom- Julian McMahon (RIP)
Silver Surfer- Julia Garner
Also Miles Teller as The Maker
TNT3149_2025-10-24 04:02
05, 2025, 2015, 05
Wataru20012025-10-24 04:05
All of First Steps. It was very well done and they all did great.
n_mcrae_19822025-10-24 04:06
I just posted in another sub that I think Elizabeth Banks would've been a better fit for the 2005/2007 films. Can I pick her?
If not, then Ioan for Reed, Vanessa for Sue, Chris for Johnny, and tie between Chiklis and Ebon for Ben.
GrayGuard972025-10-24 04:09
John Krasinski,
Emily Blunt,
Zac Efron,
Stephen Graham
+ Giancarlo Esposito,
Sterling K. Brown and Julia Garner
Jaxonoculus2025-10-24 04:09
With your rules: 2005 Thing, First Steps Invis, Fan4stic Mr. Fantastic, Chris Evans Torch, First steps Silver Surfer, Fan4stic Doom
Without your rules: First Steps Mr. Fantastic, 2005 Thing, First Steps Torch, First steps Invis, RDJ Doom, First Steps Silver Surfer.
Empty_Experience_3052025-10-24 04:18
All 05
Nonadventures2025-10-24 04:23
2025 version but a Michael B Jordan Johnny would have be intriguing
HYDRAGONIGHT2025-10-24 04:30
ALL the new ones are the best!! 🥰 I love 2025!! 😍
chevy_zr2_4x42025-10-24 04:42
Mr. Fantastic - Ioan Gruffudd
Thing - Michael Chiklis
Human Torch - Chris Evans
Sue Storm - Kate Mara, sorry I've got a thing for her!
Dr. Doom - Jury is out atm, waiting to see RDJ.
Silver Surfer - Doug Jones and Laurence Fishburne, the voice!
Kevandre2025-10-24 04:44
I'll take 2025 Reed/Sue/Ben. Strangely though, prefer the other two Johnnys. Just for the sake of making Sue and Johnny blood siblings though I'll take Chris Evans, but MBJ is fantastic and the only good part of fan4stic
rocketmanx2025-10-24 05:00
None of the Dooms do it for me.
Swimming-Young-262025-10-24 05:01
05 reed, 25 Ben, 05 Johnny, 25 Susan.
Doom/ NA. Silver Surfer NA
Affectionate_Crow3272025-10-24 05:01
2025 Sue and Johnny
2005 Reed and Ben (Ben was the best part of the 2005 films)
Nightwing06132025-10-24 05:06
Reed Richards - John Krasinski
Sue Storm - Emily Blunt
Johnny Storm/Human Torch - Zac Efron
Ben Grimm/The Thing - Liev Schreiber
Dr. Doom - Jon Hamm
Silver Surfer (Norin Radd) - Doug Jones
Mole Man - Paul Walter Hauser
Red Ghost - John Malkovich
Wooden_Passage_26122025-10-24 05:07
2025
E-Normus-Titz2025-10-24 05:22
Reed 2005
Ben 2005
Torch 2025
Sue 2025
Doom 2005
Surfer 2005
CollectMan4202025-10-24 05:27
For sue I’d like all 3
SnowBound0782025-10-24 05:34
There’s a ten year period between each reboot, cool
Lucky_Union_61922025-10-24 05:48
just the og
matchesmalone12025-10-24 05:48
No love for the 1994 crew?
MrDarkSh0ck2025-10-24 05:49
I'm picking 2025 for all of those except maybe human torch.
ModernBass2025-10-24 05:55
I'll take limp dick, mother sue, juggling juger naugts, hard shave.
Naive-Treacle20522025-10-24 05:56
Pascal, Chiklis, Evans, Kirby.
Nagraj0122025-10-24 06:42
All 3 Susans and 1 Shalla Bal. I don't care if it's wrong.
marvelstudios-ModTeam2025-10-24 16:19
... your post lacked enough effort to promote new or productive discussion to the subreddit. If you're attempting to start a discussion with a low effort screenshot or video, try making a text post where you analyse the topic of the discussion and offer your own opinion.
If you're asking an open-ended question, try to add your own personal answer and the reasoning.
Commentaires
I gobbled up their performances.
2005
2025
2005
2015
2025
2025
Doom: 1995 version
Surfer: 2025 version, her surfing was INCREDIBLE.
Ben: Very top
Johnny: Far Left
Sue: Far Right (but it’s close with JA being second)
Doom: Far Left
Silver Surfer: Left
Gonna have to go watch Hornblower again
Chiklis Thing
Evans Johnny
Alba Sue
(because I can play with them)
You know what I liked Michael b Jordan as the human torch
Same goes for Sue and Thing. 2005 versions were alright but Sue over sexualized and the Thing was not given much depth in character
Reed Richards I honestly didn't think Pedro Pascal was the best fit and John Krasinski could have had the most potential with it
Dr Doom, definitely 2005, though I'm optimistic even though there are better castings that RDJr will do a good job
And Silver Surfer definitely 2005/7
* If there wasn't a limitation: Pascal, Quinn, Kirby, Chiklis.
* Doom: Downey, even though I haven't even seen it yet, because the 2015 Doom was atrocious & I don't like McMahon in anything.
* Surfer: This one's hard because they were both good. I'll go Garner for the better visuals.
2025 Ben
2025 Johnny
2005 Sue
RDJ Doom
2025 Surfer
EDIT: didn’t realize there were more than 4 options for the F4 so
I’ll also take RDJ even though i love Julian McMahon, and then 2007 since they did it first.
Michael Chiklis's The Thing
Vanessa Kirby's Invisible Woman
Joseph Quinn's Human Torch
Julian McMahon's Dr. Doom
Laurence Fishburne's Silver Surfer
Kirby
Quinn
Chiklis w/ 2025 design.
Ben: Michael Chiklis.
Johnny: Chris Evans.
Sue: Vanessa Kirby.
The rules are kinda arbitrary (only 2 from the same team), so I broke them. The 1995 team was perfect for me, but I liked Kirby's Sue much better. I don't have a preference for Doom. And Shalla Bal and Norrin Radd are two different characters that I don't particularly wish to choose between either. Ralph Ineson's Galactus was the best yet (not that there has really been any competition).
The Thing- Michael Chiklis
Human Torch- Joseph Quinn
Invisible Woman- Jessica Alba
Dr Doom- Julian McMahon (RIP)
Silver Surfer- Julia Garner
Also Miles Teller as The Maker
If not, then Ioan for Reed, Vanessa for Sue, Chris for Johnny, and tie between Chiklis and Ebon for Ben.
Emily Blunt,
Zac Efron,
Stephen Graham
+ Giancarlo Esposito,
Sterling K. Brown and Julia Garner
Without your rules: First Steps Mr. Fantastic, 2005 Thing, First Steps Torch, First steps Invis, RDJ Doom, First Steps Silver Surfer.
Thing - Michael Chiklis
Human Torch - Chris Evans
Sue Storm - Kate Mara, sorry I've got a thing for her!
Dr. Doom - Jury is out atm, waiting to see RDJ.
Silver Surfer - Doug Jones and Laurence Fishburne, the voice!
Doom/ NA. Silver Surfer NA
2005 Reed and Ben (Ben was the best part of the 2005 films)
Sue Storm - Emily Blunt
Johnny Storm/Human Torch - Zac Efron
Ben Grimm/The Thing - Liev Schreiber
Dr. Doom - Jon Hamm
Silver Surfer (Norin Radd) - Doug Jones
Mole Man - Paul Walter Hauser
Red Ghost - John Malkovich
Ben 2005
Torch 2025
Sue 2025
Doom 2005
Surfer 2005
If you're asking an open-ended question, try to add your own personal answer and the reasoning.